Thanksgiving Pies
Made with care and unconditionally loved by our customers.
Thanksgiving Pies | Orchard Pickup
Dutch Caramel Apple
$33.00
Skip to product information
Thanksgiving Pies | Orchard Pickup
$33.00
A little orchard tradition for your Thanksgiving table
Make room for pie! Order your Thanksgiving pies from Athol Orchards Antique Apple Farm and pick them up right here at the orchard.
Thanksgiving preorder only. Please wait for an email confirming your pickup date and time; the checkout processing estimate does not apply.
Tradition Baked From the Ground Up
Bring something truly special to your Thanksgiving table this year. Baked on-site in our USDA licensed bakery at our regenerative preservation apple orchard in North Idaho, our Thanksgiving pies are handmade entirely from scratch—no shortcuts, no commercial fillings, no expense spared.
The secret starts with our gold-standard pastry: tender, ultra-flaky, and made the traditional way with premium rendered lard, sweet cream butter and certified organic ingredients. Every filling is prepared by hand, simmered and spiced in small batches, poured into freshly rolled dough, and hand-crimped - never machine stamped. Because of this, each and every pie maintains a truly rustic, classically unique and perfectly-imperfect presentation.
Reserve yours early to guarantee a premium centerpiece dessert that tastes just like Thanksgiving should - a heaping dose of love and gratitude.
All pies are 10-inch pies.
Farm pickup only. Thanksgiving pies will not be shipped.
Thanksgiving ordering deadline
Place your order by midnight at the end of November 15, 2026.
Pickup at the farm
Pickup will be at Athol Orchards Antique Apple Farm. The pickup date and time window will be announced via email to each pie customer as Thanksgiving gets closer.
Six holiday flavors
- Blue Ribbon Apple Pie — $30.00
- Dutch Caramel Apple — $33.00
- Spiced Pumpkin — $30.00
- Pumpkin Caramel Crumble — $33.00
- Classic Pecan — $33.00
- Spiced Cranberry Buttermilk — $30.00
Frequently asked questions
How do I use this?
Pancakes & More: Use it exactly like maple syrup on pancakes, waffles, and French toast.
The "Pitmaster" Secret: Brush it over ribs, salmon, or chicken during the last 15 minutes of grilling for a perfect wood-fired glaze.
Coffee & Cocktails: A splash in your morning cold brew or an evening Old Fashioned adds a sophisticated, orchard-fresh sweetness.
What's in it?
Purity First: We mean it when we say "clean", no corn syrup, no artificial preservatives, and no "yucky" additives.
The Process: Small-batch crafted using our own antique apple varieties and traditional methods to ensure a rich, authentic flavor.
When will I get my order?
We will work quickly to ship your order as soon as possible. Once your order has shipped, you will receive an email with further information. Delivery times vary depending on your location.
Where are your products manufactured?
Our products are manufactured both locally and globally. We carefully select our manufacturing partners to ensure our products are high quality and a fair value.
Does it need refrigeration?
Yes, once opened, keep refrigerated to maintain that fresh-from-the-orchard taste.